Jamieson Webster, in the Paris Review, recounts the “forced choice” of the holdup at gunpoint, posited by Jacques Lacan.
The perpetrator says to his victim: “Your money or your life!” Of course, everyone hands over their money. Yet there is an important logical error, for while you assume you have made the choice to escape scot-free, in handing over your money you have not escaped a loss of life, you’ve paid a price to live. Even as the price is worth paying, you live at a cost. Lacan used this example to demonstrate what he called a “forced choice.” Seemingly presented with options, you lose either way. There is only one choice, and you are being forced into it.